Fidonet Portal

From: Kees van Eeten (2:280/5003.4)
To: All
Date: Mon, 05.11.12 20:12
Error in the Region 17 / Net 153 segmment
Hallo Janis!

02 Nov 12 13:59, Janis Kracht wrote to Kees Van Eeten:

>> ;E DOWN,779,RoadRunner_X,Grande_Cache_Alberta,Randy_Sommerfeld,
>> -Unpublished-,9600,XX,CM,V32b,V34,V42b,
>> ;E -- Invalid keyword -- 'FILES'

>> This concerns 1:153/779 and my best guess is that the error is generated
>> on his system. That would be consistent with the second error line as
>> FILES could be the next keyword in te configuration file.

JK> No, it is NOT generated on his system nor on R17C's system.

JK> The segment from region 17 does NOT contain "DOWN", nor does it contain
JK> the word "FILES". The error reporting is what is converting the word Down
JK> to DOWN, and adding the word FILES.

JK> This would probably be a bug in the version of Makenl_ng that is run here
JK> at 1:261/38 on my 64-bit system.

JK> The version of MakeNl run here is one that Andrew has asked me to test.

JK> MakeNL 3.2.15 (GNU/Linux GCC/Linux), compiled on Oct 16 2012 13:26:38

JK> Previous release versions of MakeNl gave the same FILES error when
JK> Unpublished was used in some instances.

I have looked into this a bit more and found that I was wrong. ;(

Reading comments on the Bugtracker page I found the following:


When processing a segment with a Down,-Unpublished- entry with AllowUnpub=0, an
error message is logged "Invalid keyword -- "FILES"" . This error message needs
to be corrected to indicate the true problem: ie: -Unpublished- is only allowed
with Pvt or Hold systems, per FTS-5000.002.

Reading documents is always good.

I did my first tests with makenl 3.2.9 from the Debian Wheezy distribution.

To get a proper nodelist I had to set the option Unpublished=1.
Under those conditions the above Error is a correct Nodelist entry.
And I wondered, why it was flagged as an error.

It appears the logic for processing with AllowUnpub=0 in makenl 3.2.9 is not
in compliance with FTS-500.002 or even worse.

You are/were running 3.2.15, so I went vor recent sources on Fourceforge,
where at the momnent the current version is 3.2.17.

By working with that version I was able to reconstruct the current nodelist
as it is with the following use of AllowUnpub

Zone1 segment - AllowUnpub=0
Zone2 segment - AllowUnpub=1
Zonex segment - not relevant
Composite file - AllowUnpub=1

As noted above AllowUnpub=0 will only allow -Unpublished- together with
Pvt or Hold. The above error is a combination of -Unpublished- Down, which
is not permitted by FTS-500-002.

With respect to the weird second error line "Invalid keyword -- "FILES"
I can only say, that as far as I can read/follow the code, that line is
correct. I agree with the bugreport, that a more relevant text would be

As a solution to to the error in the nodelist, either the compliance with
FTS-5000.002 can be lifted as is done for the Composite file, or RC17/NC153
bring the line in compliance, by setting the node on Hold.

As a last I would like to commend Andrew Leary for the state of the
current code.

Kees van Eeten

--- FPD v2.9.040207 GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5
* Origin: My views are moderated by a virtual Penguin (2:280/5003.4)


This forum contains echomail areas hosted on Nightmare BBS You can browse local echomail areas, italian fidonet areas and a selection of international fidonet areas, reading messages posted by users in Nightmare BBS or even other BBSs all over the world. You can find file areas too (functional to fidonet technology). You can browse echomail areas and download files with no registration, but if you want to write messages in echomail areas, or use fidonet netmail (private messages with fidomet technology), you have to register. Only a minimal set of data is required, functional to echomail and netmail usage (name, password, email); a registration and login with facebook is provided too, to allow easy registration. If you won't follow rules (each echomail areas has its own, regularly posted in the echomail), your account may be suspended;